Blog

What Is Birth Asphyxia and When Is It Medical Malpractice in Maryland?

Posted on behalf of Peter T. Nicholl in Medical Malpractice Published on October 8, 2025 and updated on October 14, 2025.

Infant in NICU careBirth asphyxia is a serious complication that can occur during the labor and delivery of a child. This type of injury can happen if your medical provider fails to meet the acceptable standards of care in the hours leading up to the birth of your child. The resulting injuries are tragically life-altering and often completely preventable.

At The Law Offices of Peter T. Nicholl, we know that no amount of compensation can undo the trauma your family has already endured. But holding at-fault healthcare providers accountable for their actions can help provide the resources you will need for your child’s ongoing care and future needs.

Our experienced medical malpractice attorneys in Baltimore are here to provide support as we help you navigate the complex legal process of a birth injury case. We are prepared to work tirelessly on your behalf to recover the maximum possible compensation for your damages. We welcome your questions and the opportunity to help you.

Call today to discuss your situation in a FREE no-risk case review. 410-244-7005

What Exactly Is Birth Asphyxia?

Birth asphyxia is what occurs when a baby does not receive enough oxygen before birth, during labor, or right after delivery. This oxygen deprivation can happen due to problems with the umbilical cord, issues with the placenta, prolonged labor, or complications during delivery.

How and When Is Birth Asphyxia Diagnosed?

Doctors diagnose birth asphyxia through a specific range of medical tests and observations/ These tests measure the infant’s oxygen levels and overall condition. Healthcare providers typically begin diagnostic procedures immediately when they observe warning signs either during labor or within the first few hours of your baby’s birth.

These are some of the diagnostic tools medical professionals use to assess an infant for birth asphyxia:

  • Apgar Scores: Doctors evaluate the baby’s heart rate, breathing, muscle tone, reflexes, and skin color at one and five minutes after birth. Scores below 7 indicate potential oxygen deprivation.
  • Blood Gas Analysis: Healthcare providers test blood samples to measure oxygen, carbon dioxide, and acid levels. This test reveals how well the baby’s organs received oxygen during birth.
  • Umbilical Cord Blood Testing: Medical staff examine blood from the umbilical cord to determine pH levels. The acidity levels show whether the baby suffered oxygen deprivation during birth.
  • Physical Examination: Doctors assess the newborn for signs of organ dysfunction, abnormal reflexes, seizures, or other neurological symptoms that suggest a brain injury due to lack of oxygen.
  • Imaging Studies: Baltimore hospitals may order brain scans, including an MRI or ultrasound, to identify whether there is brain damage due to oxygen deprivation during the birth process.

Can I Sue for Birth Asphyxia in Maryland?

Yes, if you can prove that healthcare providers failed to meet the accepted standard of care during your child’s birth, you can file a medical malpractice lawsuit for birth asphyxia. Maryland law allows families to seek compensation for preventable birth injuries, including birth asphyxia.

Success in a Baltimore birth asphyxia case requires proving:

  • Medical professionals breached the duty of care they owed you
  • This breach directly caused your child’s injuries
  • Real damages, such as medical costs and losses, occurred

You — or your attorney — will need to demonstrate how competent healthcare providers would have acted differently under the same circumstances, leading to a better outcome for your baby. Maryland courts evaluate these cases based on established medical standards and expert testimony about how well proper care protocols were followed.

We strongly recommend seeking legal help for your birth asphyxia injury claim. These cases are extremely complex and can greatly benefit from the legal knowledge of an experienced medical malpractice attorney.

When Should Your Baltimore Doctors and Medical Staff Begin Monitoring for Birth Asphyxia?

Medical professionals should begin monitoring for birth asphyxia well before delivery begins, continuing their vigilance throughout labor and immediately after birth. Proper monitoring requires healthcare providers to assess both maternal and fetal conditions that could lead to oxygen deprivation during the birthing process.

Healthcare providers should initiate monitoring during these critical periods:

  • Prenatal Care: Doctors must identify high-risk pregnancies during routine appointments. Conditions, like maternal diabetes, high blood pressure, or previous pregnancy complications, should alert your physician to the increased risk of birth asphyxia.
  • Early Labor: Medical staff should begin continuous fetal heart monitoring during labor as soon as any changes in the baby’s heart rate indicate oxygen deprivation.
  • Active Labor: Healthcare providers must intensify monitoring as contractions strengthen, watching for signs of fetal distress that require immediate intervention to prevent oxygen loss.
  • Prolonged Labor: Doctors should increase surveillance when labor extends beyond normal timeframes, as extended delivery increases the risk of oxygen deprivation to the baby.
  • High-Risk Deliveries: Medical teams must implement enhanced monitoring for complicated births involving breech presentation, multiple babies, or other conditions that elevate birth asphyxia risks.
  • Immediate Post-Birth: Healthcare providers should continue monitoring the newborn’s breathing, heart rate, and overall condition during the first critical hours after delivery

What Are the Warning Signs of Birth Asphyxia During Labor and Delivery?

Your doctors and other medical providers are trained to recognize specific warning signs that indicate a baby is not receiving adequate oxygen during labor and delivery. It is vital that the healthcare professionals managing your labor and delivery monitor these symptoms and request immediate medical intervention as needed to prevent permanent brain damage.

Key warning signs that medical staff should recognize include:

  • Abnormal Fetal Heart Rate: The baby’s heart rate drops significantly below normal levels or shows irregular patterns that indicate the child is not receiving sufficient oxygen.
  • Decreased Fetal Movement: Reduced or absent baby movement during labor can signal oxygen deprivation, requiring immediate assessment and potential intervention by medical staff.
  • Meconium-Stained Amniotic Fluid: When the baby passes stool before birth, it can indicate fetal distress and create additional risks if the baby inhales the contaminated fluid.
  • Umbilical Cord Complications: Prolapsed, compressed, or wrapped umbilical cords can cut off oxygen supply to the baby, creating an emergency situation requiring immediate delivery.
  • Maternal Blood Pressure Issues: Sudden changes in the mother’s blood pressure can reduce oxygen flow to the baby, requiring careful monitoring and swift medical response.
  • Prolonged Labor: Extended labor periods can exhaust the baby and reduce oxygen levels, necessitating medical intervention to expedite safe delivery.
  • Placental Problems: Issues with the placenta, including separation or insufficient function, can dramatically reduce oxygen delivery to the developing baby.

How Do Baltimore Hospitals Monitor for Oxygen Deprivation During Birth?

Baltimore hospitals use advanced monitoring equipment and established protocols to track oxygen levels and detect signs of fetal distress throughout labor and delivery. These monitoring systems allow medical teams to identify potential problems early and take immediate action to protect the baby from oxygen deprivation.

Baltimore medical facilities typically use these monitoring methods:

  • Continuous Electronic Fetal Monitoring: Hospitals attach sensors to the mother’s abdomen to track the baby’s heart rate patterns. This helps them detect changes that indicate oxygen deprivation during contractions.
  • Internal Fetal Scalp Electrodes: Medical staff may place electrodes directly on the baby’s scalp for more accurate heart rate monitoring if external methods provide unclear readings.
  • Fetal Pulse Oximetry: Some Baltimore hospitals use sensors that measure oxygen levels in the baby’s blood during labor, providing direct readings of oxygen saturation.
  • Contraction Monitoring: Healthcare providers track the strength, frequency, and duration of contractions to ensure they are not compromising oxygen flow to the baby.
  • Maternal Vital Sign Assessment: Medical teams continuously monitor the mother’s blood pressure, heart rate, and oxygen levels to identify conditions that could reduce oxygen delivery to the baby.
  • Doppler Ultrasound: Hospitals use ultrasound technology to assess blood flow through the umbilical cord and detect potential circulation problems that could cause oxygen deprivation.

What Medical Errors Lead to Birth Asphyxia Malpractice Claims in Maryland?

Medical malpractice claims for birth asphyxia in Maryland can arise if healthcare providers fail to follow established medical protocols or make preventable errors during labor and delivery. These mistakes can directly cause or worsen oxygen deprivation, leading to serious injuries that could have been avoided with proper medical care.

Medical errors that result in birth asphyxia malpractice claims include:

  • Failure to Monitor Fetal Heart Rate: This error occurs when healthcare providers do not adequately track the baby’s heart patterns or ignore abnormal readings that indicate oxygen deprivation during labor.
  • Delayed Response to Fetal Distress: Medical staff who recognize warning signs but fail to take immediate action, such as emergency cesarean delivery, when the baby shows clear signs of oxygen deprivation.
  • Improper Use of Delivery Instruments: Incorrect application of forceps or vacuum extractors prolongs delivery time and increases the risk of oxygen loss to the baby.
  • Medication Errors: Administering excessive amounts of labor-inducing drugs like Pitocin that cause overly strong contractions, reducing oxygen flow to the baby between contractions.
  • Failure to Perform Timely C-Section: Delaying necessary cesarean delivery when vaginal birth poses risks to the baby’s oxygen supply, particularly in emergency situations.
  • Inadequate Management of Umbilical Cord Problems: Not recognizing or properly addressing cord compression, prolapse, or entanglement that cuts off oxygen to the baby.
  • Poor Communication Among Medical Team: Lack of coordination between doctors, nurses, and other staff if it delays critical interventions needed to prevent oxygen deprivation.

When Does Birth Asphyxia Constitute Medical Negligence Under Maryland Law?

Maryland law recognizes that not every case of birth asphyxia results from medical negligence, as some oxygen deprivation occurs despite proper medical care. The critical distinction of whether or not you have a case lies in whether the healthcare provider’s actions or inactions fell below the acceptable standard.

The acceptable standard is the care other similarly competent medical professionals would have provided in the same situation. Maryland courts focus on specific timeframes and decisions made by medical staff, examining whether delays, missed diagnoses, or improper treatments directly contributed to preventable oxygen loss.

Maryland law evaluates these cases by comparing the actual medical care provided against established clinical guidelines and accepted practices within the medical community.

What Long-Term Complications Can Result from Untreated Birth Asphyxia?

Untreated or inadequately treated birth asphyxia can cause devastating long-term complications that affect a child’s development, physical abilities, and quality of life. The severity of these complications often depends on how long the oxygen deprivation lasted and which areas of the brain sustained damage during the critical period around birth.

Children who experienced untreated birth asphyxia may develop:

  • Cerebral Palsy: Permanent movement and posture disorders that affect muscle coordination, balance, and the ability to maintain normal posture throughout life.
  • Intellectual Disabilities: Cognitive impairments that impact learning, reasoning, problem-solving, and adaptive daily living skills that typically develop during childhood.
  • Epilepsy and Seizure Disorders: Recurring seizures caused by abnormal electrical activity in brain areas damaged by oxygen deprivation during birth.
  • Vision and Hearing Problems: Sensory impairments including blindness, visual field defects, hearing loss, or complete deafness resulting from damage to sensory processing areas of the brain.
  • Speech and Language Delays: Difficulties with communication, including problems with speaking clearly, understanding language, or expressing thoughts and needs effectively.
  • Behavioral and Emotional Challenges: Attention deficit disorders, autism spectrum conditions, or emotional regulation problems that stem from brain injury sustained during birth.
  • Motor Skill Impairments: Difficulties with fine and gross motor skills that affect walking, writing, feeding, and other essential daily activities throughout the child’s life.

Why Immediate Legal Action Is Critical for Baltimore Birth Asphyxia Cases

State laws impose strict time limits for filing medical malpractice lawsuits, so prompt legal action is essential for protecting your family’s rights. In Maryland, victims may have up to three years to file a lawsuit. Claims brought on behalf of a child may have a longer time limit for the harm caused to the child, for up to three years after the child’s eighteenth birthday. However, parental rights for compensation are not similarly extended.

Three years sounds like a long time, but the fact is waiting to file your case could significantly jeopardize your ability to seek compensation for your child’s injuries. Your attorney needs time to investigate your case and gather supportive documentation on your behalf.

Early legal intervention allows attorneys to immediately take legal actions to preserve crucial evidence. Your attorney can also secure relevant medical records and identify key witnesses while memories are fresh and documentation is still easily accessible.

Need Legal Help for a Baltimore Birth Injury Case? Contact the Law Offices of Peter T. Nicholl Today

If your child suffered birth asphyxia due to medical negligence in Baltimore, you do not have to face this challenging situation alone. Our highly qualified legal team has seen how the overwhelming emotions and financial pressures impact families after a preventable birth injury.

At The Law Offices of Peter T. Nicholl, we have an experienced and knowledgeable legal team ready to fight tirelessly on your behalf to hold the at-fault medical providers accountable for their actions.

Remember that time is critical in birth asphyxia cases, and waiting too long to seek legal help can compromise your family’s legal rights and ability to recover compensation for your child’s current costs and future medical care.

Find out if you are eligible to seek compensation for your damages in a free, confidential consultation. We will review your situation at no cost, answer your questions, and explain your next steps.

Call our trusted Baltimore injury law firm today. 410-244-7005